The Scariest Golf Holes in Myrtle Beach, SC
Questions about a trip? A Golfmaster answers seven days a week.
The Scariest Golf Holes in Myrtle Beach, SC
Halloween is the one week a year when it is socially acceptable to admit that a golf hole scares you. So here they are: the nine most intimidating golf holes in Myrtle Beach, the ones with the island fairways, the forced carries over salt marsh and the greens that sit under a porch full of people holding drinks. Some of them have names that sound like a horror movie. One of them is named after a battle. All of them are on courses you can book on a Myrtle Beach golf package, which means the fear is optional but the fun is not.
We picked these using the slope ratings, the signature hole on each course, and the thing that matters most, which is how often golfers mention them afterward in the reviews that come back through our booking engine. A hole makes the list when people are still talking about it at dinner. Three of them are 13th holes. We did not plan that. The courses did.
The Nine Scariest Golf Holes in Myrtle Beach Ranked by Fear
Fear is subjective, so the order is ours. The yardages, slopes and architects are not. Each hole links to the course page where you can check live tee times, read the reviews and decide whether you are brave or just curious.
Waterloo, the 13th at the Dunes Golf and Beach Club Par 5 · Slope 148
Myrtle Beach · Robert Trent Jones, 1948 · wraps around Lake Singleton
A hole named after the battle that ended Napoleon is not trying to make friends. Waterloo bends hard to the right around Lake Singleton, and the whole hole is one long dare: cut off as much water as you think you can, then find out you were wrong. Robert Trent Jones drew it in 1948 and it has been collecting golf balls ever since, which makes the lake the oldest haunted house on the Grand Strand. The sensible play is three shots up the left and a putt for par. Nobody does the sensible play. That is the point.
Why it haunts you: the second shot. You will stand over it with a 3 wood and a feeling.
The Gambler, the 6th at King’s North Par 5 · Island Fairway
Myrtle Beach National · Arnold Palmer · slope 137
Arnold Palmer built an island fairway in the middle of a lake and then, with a straight face, offered you the choice. Go left, the long way round, and play it as an honest par 5. Or go for the island, a sliver of grass surrounded by water on all four sides, and turn it into a two shot hole. Kenny Rogers did not record a song about knowing when to walk away for nothing. Every group has one golfer who hears the name, sees the island and loses the ability to read a yardage book. Be the golfer who photographs that golfer.
Why it haunts you: if the tee shot lands, you still have to get off the island. The water is still there.
Hell’s Half Acre, the 16th at Legends Moorland Par 4 · Slope 143
Legends Golf Resort · P.B. Dye, 1990 · one of Golf Digest’s 50 toughest
You do not need us to explain the name. P.B. Dye named a bunker after the underworld and then made sure you would visit. The 16th is the hole Golf Digest had in mind when it put Moorland on its list of the 50 toughest courses in America, and the bulkheaded edges, the waste areas and the railroad ties mean every miss is a story you will be telling in the villa that night. Sand wedge, sand wedge, sand wedge, putt is a recognised scoring pattern here. Bring a rake and a sense of humor.
Why it haunts you: you can see all of it from the tee, and seeing it does not help.
The 3rd at Tidewater Par 3 · Slope 148
North Myrtle Beach · Ken Tomlinson, 1990 · carry across the salt marsh
Tidewater puts its scariest hole third, before your swing has woken up and before the coffee has done anything useful. The tee sits high above the marsh, the green sits on the far side of it, and in between is a tidal expanse that looks like a painting right up until the wind off the Intracoastal Waterway takes your ball and relocates it into Cherry Grove. The view is one of the best on the coast. Look at it, enjoy it, then club up. Then club up again.
Why it haunts you: it is the third hole. You have fifteen more to think about it.
The 13th at Heritage Club Par 3 · 235 Yards
Pawleys Island · Dan Maples, 1986 · all of it over water
Two hundred and thirty five yards from the back tee, over a lake, to a green the size of a parking lot with contours the size of speed bumps. Dan Maples built it, Mike Strantz reworked the greens, and between them they created a par 3 where the honest conversation on the tee is whether hybrid is enough. Thirteen is an unlucky number, and the hole knows it. The live oaks hanging with Spanish moss around the green are there to set the mood. The moss is not optional.
Why it haunts you: a three here is a highlight of the trip. A five is a Tuesday.
The 13th at Pawleys Plantation Par 3 · Slope 144
Pawleys Island · Jack Nicklaus, 1988 · the famous marsh hole
Another 13th, another marsh, and this one comes from Jack Nicklaus, who has never been accused of being too kind to amateurs. The green is bulkheaded on one side with wooden walls and ringed by salt marsh on the rest, and from the tee it looks less like a target and more like a suggestion. On a calm day it is a short iron and a smile. On a windy day, which in Pawleys Island is most days, it is the hole where the whole group goes quiet. The marsh does not give balls back. It has a collection.
Why it haunts you: it looks easy in the photo. The photo was taken on a calm day.
The 17th at TPC Myrtle Beach Par 3 · Slope 144
Murrells Inlet · Tom Fazio, 1999 · over water, tournament pressure included
Tom Fazio put a par 3 over water as the second to last hole on a course that hosted the Senior PGA Tour Championship, and the pros found it scary with a gallery, a caddie and a yardage book. You have a buddy who says “don’t go in the water” just before you swing. The green sits across a lake with bunkers waiting for anyone who bails out long, and the match is usually still alive when you reach it, which is precisely the problem. Dustin Johnson learned the game on this property. He hits it over the water. You might not.
Why it haunts you: it is the hole where the Nassau gets decided, and it knows.
Arnie’s Revenge, the 9th at Rivers Edge Par 5 · 570 Yards · Slope 149
Shallotte, NC · Arnold Palmer, 1999 · two carries over the Shallotte River marsh to a peninsula green
Rivers Edge carries a slope of 149, which is about as high as slope goes before the rating committee asks if you are feeling alright. The 9th is the reason, and it is the only hole on the course with a name. Arnie’s Revenge is 570 yards of par 5 that makes you carry the marsh of the Shallotte River twice, once off the tee and once on the way in, before it hands you a peninsula green so thin the reeds can read your putt. Arnold Palmer called it the most diabolical hole he designed in the eastern United States, and he was not apologizing. Play it safe and you can still walk off with a double. Go for it and the marsh birds applaud, because they are about to get another ball.
Why it haunts you: two carries means two chances to reload, and the green is the smallest target of the three.
The 18th at Caledonia Golf and Fish Club Par 4 · Slope 140
Pawleys Island · Mike Strantz, 1994 · approach over water to the porch
The scariest thing on this list is not water, sand or marsh. It is an audience. Caledonia’s closing hole asks for an approach over the lake to a green sitting directly beneath the clubhouse porch, where every golfer who finished before you is enjoying a drink and watching. They will cheer a good one. They will also, very quietly, enjoy a bad one. Mike Strantz designed the hole to be celebrated, and it is one of the best finishes on the East Coast. It is also the only hole in Myrtle Beach where a shank gets a round of applause.
Why it haunts you: the splash is loud, and the porch is close enough to hear it.
Honorable Mentions Still Scary
Nine holes was the limit, and a few others made a strong case to the committee. The 10th at the Barefoot Dye Course opens the back nine with an approach over water on a course whose slope of 149 is tied for the highest on the Grand Strand. The 3rd at World Tour Golf Links is a replica of the island green 17th at TPC Sawgrass, which means you can go in the water on the most famous par 3 in golf without leaving Myrtle Beach. The 16th and 17th at Glen Dornoch run beside the Intracoastal Waterway with enough elevation change to make a coastal course feel like a mountain one. And the 18th at True Blue closes Caledonia’s sister course over water too, because Mike Strantz liked a theme.
How to Survive a Scary Golf Hole Golfmaster Advice
Every hole on this list has a safe way to play it, and every one of them is designed to make you ignore it. A few things our Golfmasters tell groups before they go out in October and November, when the courses are at their best and the wind is at its most opinionated.
The 235 yard carry at Heritage is 235 yards from the back tee. Move up one set and it becomes a hole you can enjoy instead of one you survive. Every course on this list has four or more tee sets, and nobody on the porch at Caledonia can tell which one you played.
When a hole is named Waterloo, The Gambler or Hell’s Half Acre, the architect has told you where the trouble is. Aim at the other side. It is remarkable how often that works.
Not because you will lose them. Because your buddy will, and lending one at the Pawleys 13th is the kind of thing that gets you a free drink at the turn.
Play Tidewater or the Dunes Club on day two or three, once the swing has settled and before the legs have gone. A forced carry over salt marsh on the morning after the drive down is a trick, not a treat.
Face Them All on a Fall Golf Trip
Tell us which of these holes you want to stand on and a Golfmaster will build the trip around it, with the courses, the lodging and the tee times at one package price. Fall is the best golf weather of the year in Myrtle Beach, and the water is just as deep in November.
Slope ratings, yardages, architects and opening years are from each course’s published scorecard and the course pages on this site, current to October 2026. Slope is from the back tees and varies by tee set. Photographs are from our own course library. No golf balls were recovered in the writing of this post.
